• Skip to Content
  • Skip to Main Navigation
  • Skip to Search

IU

Indiana University Bloomington Indiana University Bloomington IU Bloomington

Menu Search
  • Home
  • Undergraduate
    • Why SPEA
    • Degrees & Majors
    • Minors & Certificates
    • Courses & Advising
    • Academic & Enrichment Programs
    • How to Apply
    • Cost & Financial Aid
    • Contact & Visit
  • Masters
    • Why SPEA?
    • Degrees & Certificates
    • How to Apply
    • Cost & Financial Aid
    • Contact & Visit
  • Doctoral
    • Degrees
    • Why SPEA
    • How to Apply
    • Cost & Financial Aid
    • On the Job Market
    • Recent Placements
    • Current Students
    • Dissertations
    • Contact
  • Faculty & Research
    • Journals & Books
    • Conferences & Workshops
    • Faculty Directory
    • Research
  • Career Development
    • About Us
    • Explore Careers & Outcomes
    • Jobs & Internships
    • Register Your Internships
    • Events & Programs
    • Alumni Resources
    • Employer Resources
    • SPEACareers Login
  • Student Experience
    • Life at SPEA
    • Life in Bloomington
    • For International Students
    • SPEA Abroad
    • Enrichment Opportunities
    • Student Organizations
    • Virtual Tour
  • About Us
    • Dean's Welcome
    • Our Mission and Guiding Values
    • Rankings
    • School Profile
    • Global and International Partnerships
    • Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
    • Bloomington & Indianapolis
    • Careers at SPEA
    • Administration & Staff Directory
    • Dean's Council
    • Publications
  • Search
  • Alumni & Giving
  • Contact Us
  • Events
  • News
  • SPEA IUPUI
  • MySPEA

SPEA School of Public and Environmental Affairs

  • Home
  • News
  • News Archive
  • 2010
  • IU graduate student: Climate talks were 'very intense,' chaotic but worthwhile

IU graduate student: Climate talks were 'very intense,' chaotic but worthwhile

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Indiana University graduate student Denise Nogueira had a front-row seat in December for the U.N. Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen -- as a member of the delegation from her home country, Brazil.

Nogueira, 24, a master's student in public affairs and environmental sciences in the School of Public and Environmental Affairs, was an intern last year with The Green Initiative, a São Paulo NGO that partners with the Brazilian government on reforestation and carbon-neutralization projects. When the president of the organization invited her to be part of its team at the climate talks, she readily accepted.

By the time the two-week conference ended with the nonbinding Copenhagen Accord, Nogueira was exhausted and coming down with the flu, but fascinated by the process she had witnessed. She answered questions for Perspectives on Policy.

Q: This must have been an extraordinary experience. What was it like?

A: It was very overwhelming, very intense. What you noticed right away was that there were two parallel conferences going on. There were the plenary sessions and closed meetings, the negotiations. Then there were a great number of civil society people, scientists, and NGOs that were there to network, to show their initiatives and establish new partnerships.

The first half of the conference, I did a lot of networking with the NGOs and the scientists, I met a lot of scientists in the field. I also learned about a lot of great initiatives going on in Brazil right now. For the last half, I just watched first-hand the intense negotiating as the politicians tried to get something out of it.

Q: Was the conference as chaotic as it appeared from news reports?

The Bella Center (where the conference took place) had a maximum capacity of 15,000 people, and they allowed something like 45,000 people to register. On the second Monday, I was going over to the center, and I was stuck in this huge crowd for like an hour; people were shoving and yelling, and it was super cold … Their solution was, from Wednesday on, almost all of the NGO members wouldn't be allowed in the building. I luckily was there as an official member of the delegation and was able to attend the conference until the end. I met a lot of people with the Brazilian delegation and I learned a lot of politics.

Q: What would you say about President Obama's final-day participation?

A: The rest of the world was demanding greater compromises from the U.S. The whole world had followed Obama's election -- people thought he's reasonable, he will do something. But he is one person and there was not enough support in the U.S. for him to make a big commitment. In Copenhagen, his hands were tied.

On the last day, when they had the presidential speeches, you could see it clearly. Lula, the president of Brazil, gave a very powerful speech, calling countries to act for one last time. At the end, everyone was applauding. Right after him, it was Obama's turn, and he wasn't very happy. What he proposed was shy of what the world expected and what we need to address the problem. He did not even stay in the plenary room, walked in and out from a side door, just to deliver the speech.

Q: At the end, the U.S., China, Brazil, India and South Africa hammered out a nonbinding accord, and the conference accepted it, but not without a lot of dissent. What was that like?

A: I was in there in the main room where the delegates were meeting, and a lot of them were mad, because this was something that the U.S. and China and three other countries agreed on behind closed doors. Finally, the Danish prime minister invited 20-some friendly nations to have one last meeting and put together a document to be voted that same night.

The plenary started at 2 or 3 in the morning, and it was very emotionally intense. I think Venezuela was the first to speak, and they were outraged; they said it was an anti-democratic process. What tickled me was that a lot of the countries that were most outraged about the lack of a democratic process, like Venezuela, Cuba and Sudan, are not democratic.

Q: There seemed to be consensus that climate change is a threat and the world needs to act. Why was it so difficult then to get an agreement?

A: I left the conference thinking the U.N. mechanism of consensus, where all the countries need to agree, is just not effective. There's so much noise, so many interests, so many little forces you don't even know of. People keep asking, "Is the science certain?" But I felt like the noisiest factor influencing our response to climate change is the politics.

What I think now is, everyone acknowledges there is potentially this threat, so are we, as humanity, going to be able to get together and do something about it? If climate change is happening, if forests need to be conserved, if green energy is the wave of the future, let's act.

It doesn't matter if we're not going to be 100 percent certain that it's anthropogenic (caused by human activity). What if we learn years from now that it's not? Forests will have been preserved, and we will have green energy, which makes sense regardless of global warming. It doesn't matter if the country next to me isn't doing enough. It's a race, and whoever starts earlier is going to be better off.

Q: Given the mixed results, did the conference accomplish anything worthwhile?

A: The conference was great as far as getting attention, making the public more aware. I felt like there was a consensus: carbon must be priced, forests must be conserved, and green energy is the wave of the future. And while the negotiators were stuck on wording, NGOs were getting together to develop projects, and the prime minister of Norway was saying, "We think the Amazon rain forest is important, so that is why we have given $1 billion to preserve it."

In the last few years, this awareness and willingness to act has increased so much. Once we reach critical mass, it's going to happen. Even though Copenhagen did not produce a comprehensive agreement, we're not very far off at this point.

SPEA Lead for the Greater Good

Indiana University

Copyright © 2018 The Trustees of Indiana University

Privacy Notice | Accessibility | Policies | Intranet

  • Undergraduate
    • Why SPEA
    • Degrees & Majors
      • Bachelor of Science in Public Affairs (BSPA)
      • Bachelor of Science in Environmental Science (BSES)
      • Bachelor of Arts in Environmental and Sustainability Studies (BAESS)
      • Bachelor of Science in Healthcare Management and Policy (BSHMP)
      • Bachelor of Science in Arts Management (BSAM)
    • Minors & Certificates
    • Courses & Advising
      • Advising
        • Advising Staff
        • Resources
      • Courses
        • Topics V260
        • Topics V450
    • Academic & Enrichment Programs
      • Honors Program
        • Honors Thesis
      • Accelerated Masters Program
      • Certificate in Applied Research & Inquiry
      • Required Internship
      • Professional Dev. Internship
    • How to Apply
      • Current IU Bloomington Students
      • High School Students
      • Transfer Students
    • Cost & Financial Aid
      • SPEA Scholarships
        • SPEA Scholarships for Current Students
        • SPEA Scholarships for Incoming Students
      • Non-SPEA Funding Opportunities
    • Contact & Visit
  • Masters
    • Why SPEA?
      • Capstone
      • Mission and Goals
    • Degrees & Certificates
      • Master of Public Affairs (MPA)
        • Concentrations
        • Capstone
        • Core Curriculum
        • Experiential Requirements
      • SPEA Connect Online MPA & Certificates
      • Master of Science in Environmental Science (MSES)
        • Concentrations
        • Capstone
        • Core Curriculum
        • Experiential Requirement
      • MPA-MSES Dual Degree
        • Components & Concentrations
      • Master of Environmental Sustainability (MES)
      • Master of Arts in Arts Administration (MAAA)
        • Curriculum
        • Opportunities for Non-Majors
        • Faculty Profiles & Publications
        • Experiential Requirements
      • MPA-MAAA Dual Degree
      • Additional Dual Degrees
        • MAAA Dual Degrees
        • MPA Dual Degrees
        • MSES Dual Degrees
      • Certificates
    • How to Apply
    • Cost & Financial Aid
      • Merit-based Aid & Fellowships
      • Volunteer Benefits & Programs
        • AmeriCorps
        • Peace Corps
        • Teach for America
      • Military and Veteran Benefits
      • Funding Opportunities
      • Need-based Aid
    • Contact & Visit
      • Request More Information
      • Virtual Information Sessions
      • Experience Days
      • Schedule a Visit
      • Connect with a Student
      • SPEA Visits You
  • Doctoral
    • Degrees
      • Ph.D. in Public Affairs
        • Environmental Policy
        • Public Finance
        • Public Management
        • Public Policy Analysis
      • Ph.D. in Environmental Science
    • Why SPEA
    • How to Apply
    • Cost & Financial Aid
      • Environmental Science Fellowship
      • Public Policy Fellowship
    • On the Job Market
    • Recent Placements
    • Current Students
    • Dissertations
    • Contact
  • Faculty & Research
    • Journals & Books
    • Conferences & Workshops
    • Faculty Directory
    • Research
      • Research Areas
      • Centers & Initiatives
      • Reports & Publications
      • Working Research Groups
        • Chemicals Policy
        • Clean Vehicles
        • Regulatory Reform
        • Shale Gas
      • Centers & Initiatives
  • Career Development
    • About Us
    • Explore Careers & Outcomes
    • Jobs & Internships
      • Greater Good Internship Fund
    • Register Your Internships
    • Events & Programs
      • Career Exploration Trips
      • Career Expo
    • Alumni Resources
    • Employer Resources
    • SPEACareers Login
  • Student Experience
    • Life at SPEA
    • Life in Bloomington
    • For International Students
    • SPEA Abroad
      • Spring Break Abroad
      • Summer Abroad
      • Semester Exchanges
      • Dual Degrees
      • Non-SPEA Programs
      • How to Apply
      • Scholarships & Funding
      • FAQ & Resources
    • Enrichment Opportunities
      • Indiana Leadership Program
      • Civic Leaders Center
        • Director's Welcome
        • Opportunities for Residents
        • How to Apply
        • Our Team
      • Washington Leadership Program
        • Internships
        • Courses & Faculty
        • Estimated costs
        • Housing & Transportation
        • How to Apply
    • Student Organizations
    • Virtual Tour
  • About Us
    • Dean's Welcome
    • Our Mission and Guiding Values
    • Rankings
    • School Profile
    • Global and International Partnerships
      • China Society
      • Vietnam Young Leaders Award
    • Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
    • Bloomington & Indianapolis
    • Careers at SPEA
    • Administration & Staff Directory
    • Dean's Council
    • Publications
  • Alumni & Giving
    • Alumni
      • Distinguished Alumni Council
      • Alumni Profiles
      • Get Involved
        • IUVisors
      • Distinguished Alumni Award
      • Alumni Board of Directors
      • Alumni Events
    • Giving
      • Ways to Give
      • For All: Bicentennial Campaign
    • Paul H. O'Neill Graduate Center
      • Groundbreaking
      • Dedication
    • Contact Us
  • Contact Us
  • Events
  • News
    • Media Report
    • Media Resources
  • SPEA IUPUI
  • MySPEA