• Skip to Content
  • Skip to Main Navigation
  • Skip to Search

IU

Indiana University Bloomington Indiana University Bloomington IU Bloomington

Menu Search
  • Home
  • Undergraduate
    • Why SPEA
    • Degrees & Majors
    • Minors & Certificates
    • Courses & Advising
    • Academic & Enrichment Programs
    • How to Apply
    • Cost & Financial Aid
    • Contact & Visit
  • Masters
    • Why SPEA?
    • Degrees & Certificates
    • How to Apply
    • Cost & Financial Aid
    • Contact & Visit
  • Doctoral
    • Degrees
    • Why SPEA
    • How to Apply
    • Cost & Financial Aid
    • On the Job Market
    • Recent Placements
    • Current Students
    • Dissertations
    • Contact
  • Faculty & Research
    • Journals & Books
    • Conferences & Workshops
    • Faculty Directory
    • Research
  • Career Development
    • About Us
    • Explore Careers & Outcomes
    • Jobs & Internships
    • Register Your Internships
    • Events & Programs
    • Alumni Resources
    • Employer Resources
    • SPEACareers Login
  • Student Experience
    • Life at SPEA
    • Life in Bloomington
    • For International Students
    • SPEA Abroad
    • Enrichment Opportunities
    • Student Organizations
    • Virtual Tour
  • About Us
    • Dean's Welcome
    • Our Mission and Guiding Values
    • Rankings
    • School Profile
    • Global and International Partnerships
    • Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
    • Bloomington & Indianapolis
    • Careers at SPEA
    • Administration & Staff Directory
    • Dean's Council
    • Publications
  • Search
  • Alumni & Giving
  • Contact Us
  • Events
  • News
  • SPEA IUPUI
  • MySPEA

SPEA School of Public and Environmental Affairs

  • Home
  • News
  • News Archive
  • 2009
  • It's All One World for Energy Concerns

It's All One World for Energy Concerns

By: Tom Price: Courtesy of Miller-McCune

Friday, July 10, 2009

Global warming, as its name suggests, will require a global response and global solutions, according to experts convened by Indiana University's School of Public and Environmental Affairs, but those global solutions don't negate the need for local tailoring.

For example, greenhouse gas emissions from developing countries have exceeded those from developed countries since 2006, said Jonathon Wiener, Duke University professor of law and environmental and public policy. One likely reason is "leakage" - an unintended consequence of cutting emissions in the developed world.

Tighter regulations in Europe may push manufacturing to China, Wiener said. But lighter regulations in China can allow greater emissions for the same amount of manufacturing, which means "leakage can exceed 100 percent."

Since greenhouse gases mix across the globe, he explained, "no matter where they're emitted or where they're abated, they have a globally mixed effect. This puts a premium on international agreement."

Participants in Indiana University's "Search for Wise Energy Policy" in Washington, D.C., didn't actually find one. (One panelist suggested it be called a "quest," rather than a search, in recognition of its Quixotic nature.) Participants didn't vote on a policy or attempt to arrive at a formal consensus, but some general themes were sounded.

For example, developed countries need to help developing countries use energy cleanly and efficiently, because poor nations must consume more energy to pull themselves out of poverty. Meanwhile, affluent countries' economies will suffer if they attack global warming without new technologies.

Global energy use cannot be cut in the foreseeable future, because a third of the world's population currently lacks access to any energy at all, said Margo Thorning, senior vice president and chief economist at the American Council for Capital Formation. Poor nations' most-critical problems can't be solved without increasing their energy use, she said.

If it doesn't increase efficiency, even the United States will need 23 percent more electricity by 2030, said Carnegie Institution President Richard Meserve.

Affluent countries face a dilemma in promoting development of technologies to control emissions, said Charles Weiss, professor in Georgetown University's School of Foreign Service. (His new book, written with William B. Bonvillian, is titled Structuring an Energy Technology Revolution.)

"We want intellectual property protection to encourage our companies to do research and development," he explained, "but we want other companies to adopt this technology."

Governments need to rethink protections so they can promote both innovation and technology transfer to developing countries, Weiss said.

Panelists identified an assortment of potential new energy sources.

Underground heat could become a larger energy source if water could be injected deep into the earth to be heated, then returned to the surface to generate electricity, Weiss said. Less expensive drilling technology needs to be developed, however, he added.

The United States has a "vast" supply of unconventional energy resources, said Jim Bartis, senior policy researcher at the RAND Corp. and former U.S. Department of Energy executive. Among them are heavy oil (which is more dense than regular oil), tar sands (a thick petroleum mixed with clay, sand and water), oil shale (rocks that release oil when heated), coal converted to liquid fuel and biomass (such as plants and garbage).

The United States' oil shale deposits are the equivalent of triple Saudi Arabia's oil reserves, Bartis said, but serious environmental challenges must be overcome. One promising idea calls for heating shale in the ground and capturing the vapor without the pollution of mining, he said, but that technology has not been developed.

Technology does exist to reduce coal's emission of greenhouse gases, Bartis said, but uncertain costs have contributed to no "clean-coal" power plants having been built.

The world is on the verge of a "nuclear renaissance," said Meserve, a former chairman of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission.

Currently, 44 nuclear power plants are under construction around the world, and many developing countries want to access nuclear power, he said. Companies in the United States have filed applications to construct 26 nuclear plants, more than three decades after the last U.S. permit was issued.

Cost and politics are the primary barriers to constructing new plants in the United States, Meserve said. Plants currently operate safely and securely, he said, and nuclear waste can be stored safely under ground.

Existing nuclear plants produce cheaper electricity than coal-fired plants, he said, but that's partly because their construction costs have been amortized. Building a new plant today would cost $3 billion to $6 billion, which he described as a "bet-your-company" investment.

The nuclear power infrastructure also must be reconstituted, a decade and a half after the last plant went on line, he said. "You need to rebuild the network of suppliers" and address the fact that "a large number of schools shut down their nuclear engineering departments."

by Tom Price

Courtesy of Miller-McCune

SPEA Lead for the Greater Good

Indiana University

Copyright © 2018 The Trustees of Indiana University

Privacy Notice | Accessibility | Policies | Intranet

  • Undergraduate
    • Why SPEA
    • Degrees & Majors
      • Bachelor of Science in Public Affairs (BSPA)
      • Bachelor of Science in Environmental Science (BSES)
      • Bachelor of Arts in Environmental and Sustainability Studies (BAESS)
      • Bachelor of Science in Healthcare Management and Policy (BSHMP)
      • Bachelor of Science in Arts Management (BSAM)
    • Minors & Certificates
    • Courses & Advising
      • Advising
        • Advising Staff
        • Resources
      • Courses
        • Topics V260
        • Topics V450
    • Academic & Enrichment Programs
      • Honors Program
        • Honors Thesis
      • Accelerated Masters Program
      • Certificate in Applied Research & Inquiry
      • Required Internship
      • Professional Dev. Internship
    • How to Apply
      • Current IU Bloomington Students
      • High School Students
      • Transfer Students
    • Cost & Financial Aid
      • SPEA Scholarships
        • SPEA Scholarships for Current Students
        • SPEA Scholarships for Incoming Students
      • Non-SPEA Funding Opportunities
    • Contact & Visit
  • Masters
    • Why SPEA?
      • Capstone
      • Mission and Goals
    • Degrees & Certificates
      • Master of Public Affairs (MPA)
        • Concentrations
        • Capstone
        • Core Curriculum
        • Experiential Requirements
      • SPEA Connect Online MPA & Certificates
      • Master of Science in Environmental Science (MSES)
        • Concentrations
        • Capstone
        • Core Curriculum
        • Experiential Requirement
      • MPA-MSES Dual Degree
        • Components & Concentrations
      • Master of Environmental Sustainability (MES)
      • Master of Arts in Arts Administration (MAAA)
        • Curriculum
        • Opportunities for Non-Majors
        • Faculty Profiles & Publications
        • Experiential Requirements
      • MPA-MAAA Dual Degree
      • Additional Dual Degrees
        • MAAA Dual Degrees
        • MPA Dual Degrees
        • MSES Dual Degrees
      • Certificates
    • How to Apply
    • Cost & Financial Aid
      • Merit-based Aid & Fellowships
      • Volunteer Benefits & Programs
        • AmeriCorps
        • Peace Corps
        • Teach for America
      • Military and Veteran Benefits
      • Funding Opportunities
      • Need-based Aid
    • Contact & Visit
      • Request More Information
      • Virtual Information Sessions
      • Experience Days
      • Schedule a Visit
      • Connect with a Student
      • SPEA Visits You
  • Doctoral
    • Degrees
      • Ph.D. in Public Affairs
        • Environmental Policy
        • Public Finance
        • Public Management
        • Public Policy Analysis
      • Ph.D. in Environmental Science
    • Why SPEA
    • How to Apply
    • Cost & Financial Aid
      • Environmental Science Fellowship
      • Public Policy Fellowship
    • On the Job Market
    • Recent Placements
    • Current Students
    • Dissertations
    • Contact
  • Faculty & Research
    • Journals & Books
    • Conferences & Workshops
    • Faculty Directory
    • Research
      • Research Areas
      • Centers & Initiatives
      • Reports & Publications
      • Working Research Groups
        • Chemicals Policy
        • Clean Vehicles
        • Regulatory Reform
        • Shale Gas
      • Centers & Initiatives
  • Career Development
    • About Us
    • Explore Careers & Outcomes
    • Jobs & Internships
      • Greater Good Internship Fund
    • Register Your Internships
    • Events & Programs
      • Career Exploration Trips
      • Career Expo
    • Alumni Resources
    • Employer Resources
    • SPEACareers Login
  • Student Experience
    • Life at SPEA
    • Life in Bloomington
    • For International Students
    • SPEA Abroad
      • Spring Break Abroad
      • Summer Abroad
      • Semester Exchanges
      • Dual Degrees
      • Non-SPEA Programs
      • How to Apply
      • Scholarships & Funding
      • FAQ & Resources
    • Enrichment Opportunities
      • Indiana Leadership Program
      • Civic Leaders Center
        • Director's Welcome
        • Opportunities for Residents
        • How to Apply
        • Our Team
      • Washington Leadership Program
        • Internships
        • Courses & Faculty
        • Estimated costs
        • Housing & Transportation
        • How to Apply
    • Student Organizations
    • Virtual Tour
  • About Us
    • Dean's Welcome
    • Our Mission and Guiding Values
    • Rankings
    • School Profile
    • Global and International Partnerships
      • China Society
      • Vietnam Young Leaders Award
    • Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
    • Bloomington & Indianapolis
    • Careers at SPEA
    • Administration & Staff Directory
    • Dean's Council
    • Publications
  • Alumni & Giving
    • Alumni
      • Distinguished Alumni Council
      • Alumni Profiles
      • Get Involved
        • IUVisors
      • Distinguished Alumni Award
      • Alumni Board of Directors
      • Alumni Events
    • Giving
      • Ways to Give
      • For All: Bicentennial Campaign
    • Paul H. O'Neill Graduate Center
      • Groundbreaking
      • Dedication
    • Contact Us
  • Contact Us
  • Events
  • News
    • Media Report
    • Media Resources
  • SPEA IUPUI
  • MySPEA